NSW government suspends underquoting reforms hours before launch

by Endah Setiawati • 14 hours ago
NSW government suspends underquoting reforms hours before launch

Share It:

On 16 November, the New South Wales government halted the rollout of its NSW underquoting reforms just hours before they were slated to begin on 17 November.

The pause puts mandatory price guides, a ban on advertising below rejected offers and fines of up to $110,000 on hold, with officials suggesting the suspension could last as long as a year.

Existing underquoting rules remain in force, meaning agents must still avoid advertising prices that lack reasonable justification.

How the reforms were pulled

After months of preparation, NSW Fair Trading released detailed guidance on 29 October, and the government formally confirmed a 17 November start on 1 November.

Premier Chris Minns intervened the next day, announcing the start date was being shelved. The legislation itself had already passed Parliament in June.

Industry insiders reported that agents had spent a month revising processes and advertising templates, only to be told the changes would not be required for now.

Key provisions that were to take effect

The first change required agents to display a price or price range, effectively ending “price on application” listings across the state.

The second barred sellers from advertising a property below a written offer the vendor had previously rejected, or below the highest bid at a passed-in auction.

The third raised the maximum penalty for the practice from $22,000 to that amount or three times the agent’s commission, whichever is higher.

Additional rules would have forced price estimates to be based on the three most comparable recent sales and required any change to be reflected in advertising within one business day.

Premier Minns noted a 9.4% decline in property prices over the 12 months to October and said the legislation “believed that the prices would always rise.”

Minister for Better Regulation and Fair Trading Anoulack Chanthivong said the laws were passed “at a different time and in a different economic and housing market.” He added the government would not proceed while households face financial pressure.

Shadow Fair Trading Minister Tim James made a fair point when he said the laws should have been designed to withstand a downturn in the first place, noting that “property prices move in cycles.”

Real Estate Institute of NSW chief executive Tim McKibbin welcomed the delay but criticized the government’s handling, saying “governments should be stable” and noting that the institute’s requests for meetings had been refused.

He also pointed out that the practice complaints tend to fall in a downturn because agents are pressured to quote realistically when buyers hold more leverage.

Under current law, agents must have reasonable grounds for any advertised estimate and must revise it when new evidence shows the price is no longer justified, including when a higher offer is received.

The suspended measures were the more prescriptive requirements and the substantially higher fines; the core anti-underquoting provisions remain active.

Because a government announcement does not automatically become enforceable regulation, agents are advised to verify the present obligations directly with NSW Fair Trading rather than relying on media summaries.

Implications for participants

Under the unchanged legislation, agents must still substantiate any advertised estimate with evidence from comparable recent sales.

They are also required to adjust a guide price promptly when new information, such as a higher offer, emerges.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *